What do borrowers consider when choosing a lender?


Posted: November 16, 2026 | Word Count: 938

Key takeaways:

  • Over half of Americans age 18 to 64 are open to taking out a loan in the near future, according to a new defi SOLUTIONS survey.
  • Borrowers prioritize affordability and hybrid experiences that offer digital convenience with easy access to a person.
  • Financial priorities differ by age group as younger adults seek rapid approval while older demographics focus primarily on cost savings.

Making a major purchase, like buying a home or car, is often a defining moment in many Americans' lives — and typically one that requires a loan. Yet these days, it's becoming increasingly complicated as interest rates fluctuate, inflation continues to affect prices and many people are increasingly cautious, researching options before taking on additional debt.

In fact, 55.1% of Americans say they try to avoid debt whenever possible, according to a survey by defi SOLUTIONS of U.S. consumers ages 18 to 64. However, that same survey also found over half of Americans (52.2%) are open to borrowing in the near future, with 21.7% considering a loan in the next six months and 19.9% before the end of 2027.

This tension can be puzzling for lenders as they try to pinpoint what tips the scale for borrowers in this current landscape.

"Consumer loan demand has been subdued, but our research suggests the tide could be starting to shift," said Tom Allanson, CEO at defi SOLUTIONS. "More than half of consumers are considering borrowing, and as that demand returns, lenders will be competing for borrowers whose expectations have evolved."

Allanson went on to say, "Affordability will always matter, but today's borrower is also shopping around and evaluating the entire experience, from the first interaction to the ease of the digital process to the ability to reach a person when needed. Lenders should be taking a hard look at whether they're prepared to deliver on those expectations."

Allanson shares top data points and trends influencing the current borrower landscape:

Borrowers are picky and lender trust can be a dealbreaker

Trends show that borrowers are shopping around when considering a loan. Nearly half of the respondents surveyed compare three or more lenders while 30.5% compare two before deciding. Only 22.1% go straight to one lender. Before making a decision, borrowers first consider interest rate and loan term, but lender trustworthiness and reputation are a close second. This means trust often decides where people start shopping, even if price determines their final decision.

Many borrowers first look at their current financial institution before comparing word-of-mouth recommendations and other online resources. Existing relationships still matter, but they no longer guarantee loyalty: one in four borrowers start comparing options before ever engaging with their own lender. First impressions can also influence whether borrowers move forward: 61.2% said their first interaction with a lender is "very important," while another 35.7% said it is somewhat important.

  • Affordability is the top priority: Interest rates (47.8%) and low monthly payments (38.6%) are the most critical factors influencing a borrower's final decision.

  • Borrowers shop around and value trust: Over 77% of consumers compare multiple options before choosing, and while existing banking relationships matter, lender trustworthiness and reputation heavily dictate where shoppers start their search.

  • A hybrid digital-human experience wins: Nearly half of borrowers prefer digital loan processes paired with easy access to human customer support when needed.

  • First impressions matter: Over 96% of respondents consider their very first interaction with a lender to be important, with 61.2% rating it as "very important."

  • Borrower priorities shift by generation: Younger adults (25–34) show the highest immediate demand for loans and value approval speed, whereas older adults (55–64) focus primarily on securing lower interest rates.

Affordability will always matter, but today's borrower is also shopping around and evaluating the entire experience, from the first interaction to the ease of the digital process to the ability to reach a person when needed.

Tom Allanson, CEO at defi SOLUTIONS

Borrowers prioritize affordability and hybrid experiences that offer digital convenience with easy access to a person

When it comes to application and customer experience, almost half of borrowers favor digital options with access to human support: That middle-ground preference leads the industry right now. Less than 18% want a fully automated process, while nearly 25% still prefer working with a person directly.

The best solution is a hybrid one: Make digital effortless by having a person easily available for support when needed. Lenders who win right now are the ones who show up with a genuinely competitive rate, explain their terms clearly, and don't make the borrower choose between an app and a human.

Borrower expectations can vary by generation

Both economics and experience shape the borrower journey, but age and stage of life are strong indicators of when consumers will seek out a loan. Adults ages 25 to 34 showed the strongest near-term demand, with 41.9% considering a loan within the next six months, while older borrowers are more focused on cost as 47.8% of those ages 55 to 64 said a lower interest rate would most increase their willingness to borrow.

Younger consumers placed comparatively more emphasis on speed, with 24.5% of 18- to 24-year-olds preferring faster approvals. Across generations, however, there's an opportunity for lenders to pair digital convenience with human support while adapting the experience to different borrower priorities.

Affordability matters most to borrowers

Above everything else, affordability is what drives loan decisions. When evaluating a loan, 47.8% said the best interest rate matters most, followed by the lowest monthly payment at 38.6%.

To learn more, read the defi SOLUTIONS 2026 Borrower Outlook report.

Get a free feed to have stories like this automatically added to your website.

Get Content Feed
This sponsored story is available to download for free use in print and online publications. If you must edit the content, please include at least one brand reference. All stories must retain the (BPT) or Brandpoint byline.
Text-only download. Create a free account to include images.
If available, images associated with a story can be published only as an accompaniment to that story's text. Any other use is prohibited.